← All writingMathematics blog

Vector bundles on A² − 0

The punctured affine plane is a non-affine scheme on which every vector bundle is trivial.

Background

The Quillen–Suslin theorem says that every vector bundle over affine space over a field is trivial. There are also non-affine schemes with this property. The goal of this post is to prove one example, namely the punctured affine plane.

Let kk be a field, write Ak2=Spec⁡(k[x,y])\A_k^2=\Spec(k[x,y]), and set

U:=Ak2∖0=Ak2∖{(x,y)}.U:=\A_k^2\setminus0=\A_k^2\setminus\{(x,y)\}.

Throughout, a vector bundle means a locally free sheaf of finite rank. Following the terminology in my paper, a scheme is Serre if every vector bundle on it is trivial. More generally, a morphism f ⁣:X→Yf\colon X\to Y is Serre if the induced functor

f∗ ⁣:Vect⁡(Y)⟶Vect⁡(X)f^*\colon\Vect(Y)\longrightarrow\Vect(X)

is essentially surjective. Observe that if ff is Serre and YY is a Serre scheme, then XX too is a Serre scheme, because pullback preserves trivial bundles.

Theorem 1. The open immersion j ⁣:U↪Ak2j\colon U\hookrightarrow\A_k^2 is a Serre morphism of schemes. In particular, UU is a non-affine Serre scheme.

We will use the Quillen–Suslin theorem in this proof. Its proof is divided into Quillen–Suslin 1: Serre’s reduction and Quillen–Suslin 2: Vaserstein’s proof; the version we need allows a PID as the coefficient ring.

For any open immersion j ⁣:U↪Xj\colon U\hookrightarrow X, there is a canonical isomorphism j∗j∗E≅Ej^*j_*\E\cong\E. Hence, if the pushforward of every vector bundle on UU is a vector bundle on XX, then jj is Serre. This is how we will prove the theorem. The argument proceeds in three steps: j∗Ej_*\E is coherent, it is reflexive, and finally it is locally free.

We must first study the open subscheme U⊂Ak2U\subset\A_k^2. Observe that D(x)∪D(y)=UD(x)\cup D(y)=U and D(x)∩D(y)=D(xy)D(x)\cap D(y)=D(xy). Therefore the sheaf condition shows that

Γ(U,OU)→k[x±1,y]↓↓k[x,y±1]→k[x±1,y±1]\begin{CD} \Gamma(U,\O_U) @>>> k[x^{\pm1},y] \\ @VVV @VVV \\ k[x,y^{\pm1}] @>>> k[x^{\pm1},y^{\pm1}] \end{CD}

is a pullback square. Both maps to the bottom-right corner are inclusions, and so

Γ(U,OU)=k[x±1,y]∩k[x,y±1]=k[x,y].\Gamma(U,\O_U) =k[x^{\pm1},y]\cap k[x,y^{\pm1}] =k[x,y].

Indeed, a Laurent polynomial belonging to the first ring has no negative powers of yy, and one belonging to the second has no negative powers of xx.

In particular, the restriction map

Γ(Ak2,OAk2)⟶Γ(U,OU)\Gamma(\A_k^2,\O_{\A_k^2})\longrightarrow\Gamma(U,\O_U)

is an isomorphism. If UU were affine, the open immersion jj would therefore be an isomorphism of affine schemes, which it is not. Thus UU is non-affine.

The proof

Coherence

The schemes Ak2\A_k^2 and UU are Noetherian. The open immersion jj is quasicompact and quasiseparated, so j∗j_* preserves quasicoherence. Moreover, over a Noetherian scheme, a quasicoherent sheaf is coherent exactly when it is of finite type. Any vector bundle E\E on UU is coherent; we need to show that its pushforward is of finite type as well.

Lemma 2. Let E\E be a vector bundle on UU. Then j∗Ej_*\E is coherent on Ak2\A_k^2.

Proof. Set R=k[x,y]R=k[x,y]. Since Ak2\A_k^2 is affine, we can write

j∗E=M~,M=Γ(Ak2,j∗E)=Γ(U,E).j_*\E=\wt M, \qquad M=\Gamma(\A_k^2,j_*\E)=\Gamma(U,\E).

It suffices to prove that MM is a finitely generated RR-module.

Consider the affine open cover {D(x),D(y)}\{D(x),D(y)\} of UU. We claim that both opens are Serre schemes. Indeed,

D(x)=Spec⁡(k[x±1][y]),D(y)=Spec⁡(k[y±1][x]),D(x)=\Spec(k[x^{\pm1}][y]), \qquad D(y)=\Spec(k[y^{\pm1}][x]),

and k[z±1]=k[z]zk[z^{\pm1}]=k[z]_z is a PID, being a localization of a PID. The Quillen–Suslin theorem therefore applies to both rings. Thus we can choose trivializations

E∣D(x)≅OD(x)⊕n,E∣D(y)≅OD(y)⊕n.\E|_{D(x)}\cong\O_{D(x)}^{\oplus n}, \qquad \E|_{D(y)}\cong\O_{D(y)}^{\oplus n}.

The ranks agree because the overlap is nonempty and connected.

Let T∈GLn(Rxy)T\in\mathrm{GL}_n(R_{xy}) be the transition matrix which converts the second trivialization to the first on D(xy)D(xy). The sheaf condition identifies the global sections with

M≅Rx⊕n∩TRy⊕n⊂Rxy⊕n.M\cong R_x^{\oplus n}\cap T R_y^{\oplus n} \subset R_{xy}^{\oplus n}.

Choose a≥0a\geq0 large enough to clear all powers of xx from the denominators of the entries of TT. Then xaTx^aT has entries in RyR_y, and consequently

xaM⊂Rx⊕n∩Ry⊕n=R⊕n.x^aM \subset R_x^{\oplus n}\cap R_y^{\oplus n} =R^{\oplus n}.

It follows that MM is an RR-submodule of the finite free module x−aR⊕nx^{-a}R^{\oplus n}. Since RR is Noetherian, MM is finitely generated, as required. □

The bound on the denominators is needed here. The sheaf condition alone gives an injection into Rx⊕n⊕Ry⊕nR_x^{\oplus n}\oplus R_y^{\oplus n}, but those localized modules are not finite over RR.

Reflexivity

It is at this point that we need some more powerful tools, namely reflexive sheaves. If F\F is a coherent sheaf on a locally Noetherian scheme XX, write

F∗:=HomOX(F,OX),F∗∗:=HomOX(F∗,OX)\F^*:=\mathcal{H}om_{\O_X}(\F,\O_X), \qquad \F^{**}:=\mathcal{H}om_{\O_X}(\F^*,\O_X)

for its dual and double dual. We say that F\F is reflexive if the canonical evaluation map F→F∗∗\F\to\F^{**} is an isomorphism. Every vector bundle is reflexive. For coherent sheaves over a locally Noetherian scheme, duals commute with localization, so reflexivity can be checked on stalks.

We use the following facts, which are the same ingredients as in the paper.

Proposition 3. Let XX be a locally Noetherian scheme and F\F a coherent sheaf on XX.

  1. Suppose j ⁣:U↪Xj\colon U\hookrightarrow X is an open immersion and depth⁡(Fz)≥2\depth(\F_z)\geq2 for every z∈X∖Uz\in X\setminus U. Then the canonical map F→j∗j∗F\F\to j_*j^*\F is an isomorphism. See Stacks, Tag 0E9I.

  2. If XX is integral, then F∗∗\F^{**} is coherent and reflexive. See Stacks, Tag 0EBH.

  3. If XX is integral, F\F is reflexive, and depth⁡(OX,z)≥2\depth(\O_{X,z})\geq2, then depth⁡(Fz)≥2\depth(\F_z)\geq2. See Stacks, Tag 0EBI.

The first statement says that a coherent sheaf with sufficient depth at the missing points can be recovered from its restriction. This is the scheme-theoretic ingredient of the argument; the other statements follow from their commutative algebra counterparts.

Theorem 4. Let E\E be a vector bundle on U⊂Ak2U\subset\A_k^2. Then j∗Ej_*\E is a coherent reflexive sheaf on Ak2\A_k^2.

Proof. Set F=j∗E\F=j_*\E, which is coherent by Lemma 2. Its double dual F∗∗\F^{**} is reflexive by Proposition 3(2). Since jj is an open immersion,

j∗(F∗∗)≅(j∗F)∗∗≅E∗∗≅E.j^*(\F^{**})\cong(j^*\F)^{**}\cong\E^{**}\cong\E.

At the origin, the local ring

OAk2,0=k[x,y](x,y)\O_{\A_k^2,0}=k[x,y]_{(x,y)}

is regular local of dimension and depth two. Applying Proposition 3(3) to F∗∗\F^{**} gives

depth⁡(F0∗∗)≥2.\depth(\F^{**}_0)\geq2.

The origin is the only point outside UU, so Proposition 3(1) now shows that the canonical map

F∗∗⟶j∗j∗(F∗∗)\F^{**}\longrightarrow j_*j^*(\F^{**})

is an isomorphism.

To check that this makes F\F reflexive, consider the natural square

F→F∗∗↓↓j∗j∗F→j∗j∗(F∗∗).\begin{CD} \F @>>> \F^{**} \\ @VVV @VVV \\ j_*j^*\F @>>> j_*j^*(\F^{**}). \end{CD}

The left arrow is an isomorphism because F=j∗E\F=j_*\E, the right arrow is an isomorphism by the depth argument, and the bottom arrow is an isomorphism because E\E is locally free. Hence the top arrow, which is the evaluation map, is an isomorphism as well. □

Local freeness

We can finish with one additional commutative algebra lemma.

Lemma 5. Let RR be a regular local ring. Any finite maximal Cohen–Macaulay RR-module is free.

This is Stacks, Tag 00NT. Recall that a nonzero finite module is maximal Cohen–Macaulay when its depth equals dim⁡R\dim R. One way to see the lemma is the Auslander–Buchsbaum formula: a finite module over a regular local ring has finite projective dimension, and

pd⁡RM+depth⁡M=depth⁡R=dim⁡R.\operatorname{pd}_R M+\depth M=\depth R=\dim R.

Thus a maximal Cohen–Macaulay module has projective dimension zero, and finite projective modules over a local ring are free.

Corollary 6. Every coherent reflexive sheaf on Ak2\A_k^2 is a vector bundle.

Proof. Let F\F be such a sheaf and z∈Ak2z\in\A_k^2. The local ring R=OAk2,zR=\O_{\A_k^2,z} is regular, with dimension 00, 11, or 22. We consider these cases separately.

If dim⁡R=0\dim R=0, then RR is a field and the finite RR-module Fz\F_z is free. If dim⁡R=1\dim R=1, then RR is a discrete valuation ring. A reflexive module over a domain is torsion-free, so the finite module Fz\F_z is again free.

Finally, suppose dim⁡R=2\dim R=2. Since a regular local ring has depth equal to its dimension, Proposition 3(3) gives depth⁡(Fz)≥2\depth(\F_z)\geq2. If Fz≠0\F_z\neq0, its depth is at most dim⁡R=2\dim R=2, so it is maximal Cohen–Macaulay. By Lemma 5, it is free; the zero module is free as well.

Thus every stalk of F\F is finite free. Since F\F is coherent, a basis at a stalk extends to a basis on some neighborhood, so F\F is locally free. □

We have now completed all three steps. Given a vector bundle E\E on UU, the sheaf j∗Ej_*\E is coherent by Lemma 2, reflexive by Theorem 4, and locally free by Corollary 6. Since

j∗j∗E≅E,j^*j_*\E\cong\E,

the immersion jj is Serre. The Quillen–Suslin theorem says that the vector bundle j∗Ej_*\E on Ak2\A_k^2 is trivial, and pulling back shows that E\E is trivial as well. Together with the calculation of global functions, this proves Theorem 1.

We have at last shown that Ak2∖0\A_k^2\setminus0 is a Serre scheme which is not affine.

For the proof of Quillen–Suslin used here, see Quillen–Suslin 1: Serre’s reduction and Quillen–Suslin 2: Vaserstein’s proof. For more context about Serre schemes and morphisms, see the paper version, Serre Schemes and the Quillen–Suslin Theorem.

Back to the blog →