This is a short exposition on P. Deligne's Tannakian reconstruction theorems regarding certain tensor categories. The definitions needed to state the theorems, although relatively simple, are numerous; hence the goal is to state the results and discuss examples, particularly in representation theory and algebraic geometry.
The main sources are Deligne's Catégories tensorielles and Catégories tannakiennes, together with Deligne–Milne's Tannakian Categories. Most proofs can be found in those papers and will be omitted here for brevity.
Tannakian duality
The goal of Tannakian reconstruction or duality is to recover an object from its associated category of representations, appropriately construed. In most scenarios this is not possible, so one determines under what conditions it can be done. “Tannakian” usually connotes that the category should be viewed with a symmetric monoidal structure.
There are two classes of reconstruction theorems. One asks whether a representation category determines the underlying object. The other asks when we can, given a category satisfying some properties, produce an object whose representations are that category. Deligne's theorems are of the latter form. We begin with some examples of the former.
If is a ring, its category of modules is its category of representations. We might ask when an additive equivalence
implies . It does, for instance, if and are commutative: the endomorphism ring of the identity functor on is the center of . In general this is the theory of Morita equivalence. For commutative rings, if the equivalence also preserves the usual tensor products, the ring can be recovered directly as the endomorphisms of the tensor unit.
We may ask the same thing for representations of a group in sets. Write for the category of left -sets.
Theorem 1. Let be groups such that . Then .
Proof. The regular left -set is, up to isomorphism, the unique nonempty indecomposable projective object of . Indeed, an indecomposable nonempty -set is transitive, hence of the form . If it is projective, the surjection has a -equivariant section. Every point of has trivial stabilizer, so such a section forces . Conversely, the regular -set is projective because a map out of it is determined by the image of the identity, and that image lifts across any surjection.
An equivalence preserves these categorical properties, and hence identifies the automorphism groups of the two regular objects. Since
and similarly for , we recover . □
There is also a reconstruction which remembers the forgetful functor . The regular object represents , so the Yoneda lemma gives
This is particularly close to the reconstruction by a fiber functor that we will encounter later.
If we think of as a one-object groupoid, then . It is natural to think of
as a category of representations of an arbitrary small category . In this setting a presheaf category determines the idempotent completion of : the category obtained by formally splitting every idempotent as a section–retraction pair. More precisely, if and only if the idempotent completions of and are equivalent. In particular, if and are already idempotent complete, an equivalence of their presheaf categories implies .
Our example of commutative rings shows that affine schemes and with an additive equivalence
are isomorphic. The case becomes more interesting when the schemes are not affine. Under suitable hypotheses, even the bounded derived category of coherent sheaves determines the scheme; the Bondal–Orlov reconstruction theorem is one example.
Deligne's theorem instead starts with a potential representation category. Roughly, it says that a suitable abelian symmetric tensor category in characteristic zero is a category of super-representations if every object is annihilated by some Schur functor. The ordinary version requires the stronger condition that sufficiently large exterior powers vanish. We will state both precisely after explaining the terminology.
Hopf algebras
Let be a symmetric monoidal category. We will suppress associators and unitors, inserting them where needed by the coherence theorem. We must retain the symmetry
in the super setting, it will carry an essential sign.
Recall that a monoid in is an object equipped with multiplication and unit such that
commutes, and
A comonoid in is a monoid in . We write its structure maps as
A monoid is commutative if ; a comonoid is cocommutative if .
A morphism of monoids is a morphism satisfying
and likewise for comonoids with the arrows reversed. These form categories and . Some examples are
In the second example the morphisms on the right are strict monoidal functors. There are also canonical equivalences
whenever the indicated finite coproducts or products exist. The corresponding multiplication is the fold map, or comultiplication the diagonal. In general, forgetting the structure gives a faithful functor .
A bialgebra or bimonoid in is an object with both structures, subject to compatibility. Concretely, the comultiplication and counit must be monoid morphisms. Thus
and, with the canonical identifications involving understood,
For example, if is semiadditive, every object has a unique bimonoid structure for , using its fold and diagonal maps. In with , we recover the usual notion of a bialgebra.
Let be the polynomial algebra. It has a coalgebra structure determined by
where extends as an algebra homomorphism. These maps make a bialgebra.
Finally, a Hopf algebra in is a bialgebra equipped with an antipode such that
These again form a category . For example,
and taking recovers classical Hopf algebras. For the polynomial bialgebra above, setting gives a Hopf algebra.
A nice geometric example is the cohomology of a compact Lie group. Over a field , the cup product makes a graded algebra, and the group multiplication induces
The identity and inverse give the counit and antipode. This is a Hopf algebra in graded vector spaces, with the graded symmetry, and the assignment is contravariant in . Compactness gives finite-dimensional cohomology, so the indicated Künneth identification applies without additional finiteness issues. For fun, Lie groups themselves can be described as .
Superalgebra
We now discuss superobjects, which means objects with a grading. A super vector space over is a vector space with a decomposition
We think of as the even subspace and as the odd subspace. A nonzero homogeneous element belongs to one of these summands, and its parity records which one.
Direct sums are defined componentwise. For tensor products, we set
Similarly, the space of linear maps has a grading: consists of maps preserving parity, while consists of maps reversing it.
The category has super vector spaces as objects and even linear maps as morphisms. Thus its ordinary morphism spaces are -vector spaces. It also has an internal super-Hom, whose even and odd parts are the spaces just described.
The symmetric monoidal structure uses the Koszul rule:
for homogeneous elements. The forgetful functor is faithful and strong monoidal. It does not preserve this symmetry in characteristic different from two: interchanging two odd factors introduces a minus sign.
There is also a canonical functor sending to the purely even space . All linear maps between purely even spaces preserve parity, so is fully faithful. If takes the even summand, then
exhibits an adjunction .
On the other hand, a linear map amounts to a pair of maps into and . Define by placing one copy of in each parity. Then
giving . Notice that . Reversing the same arguments gives the other adjunctions:
Thus and as well. These are adjunctions of the underlying categories; the two adjoint pairs provide useful ways to pass between ordinary and super vector spaces.
Because of our generality in the previous section, we can apply the definitions to to get superalgebras, superbialgebras, and Hopf superalgebras. Commutativity with respect to the Koszul symmetry is exactly supercommutativity:
For a supercommutative algebra, is an ordinary commutative subalgebra. Products of odd elements lie in , and in characteristic different from two every odd element squares to zero. Given superalgebras , their tensor product has multiplication
on homogeneous tensors.
We finish this part with examples. Let be a group and consider the group algebra . Define, for every ,
and extend linearly. This gives a Hopf algebra. If is finite, its linear dual
is the Hopf algebra of -valued functions on . Its product is pointwise multiplication, and its comultiplication, counit, and antipode are
More generally, the dual of a finite-dimensional Hopf algebra is again a Hopf algebra. Finite dimensionality matters: the dual of a multiplication need not land in when is infinite-dimensional. We will use coordinate Hopf algebras directly when discussing general algebraic groups.
For a super example, take an odd generator and the exterior algebra . It becomes a Hopf superalgebra by
Here the Koszul sign ensures that the square of is zero, as required.
Tensor categories
We now define the categories to which Deligne's theorem applies. From this point on, let be algebraically closed of characteristic zero. Write and for the finite-dimensional categories.
Definition 2 (Tensor category).¶ For this discussion, a -tensor category is an essentially small abelian -linear symmetric monoidal category such that the tensor product is -linear and exact in each variable, every object has a dual, and the natural map is an isomorphism.
The abelian and exactness conditions allow us to discuss subobjects and quotients; the remaining conditions describe the tensor structure. Let us work backwards through them.
That is -linear means its morphism sets are -vector spaces and composition is bilinear. An object has a left dual if there are maps
such that the composites
are identities. Right duals are defined similarly. In a symmetric monoidal category, a left dual supplies a right dual using the symmetry. A monoidal category is rigid if every object has both.
Both and are rigid, by taking linear duals, and satisfy Definition 2. Finite dimensionality is essential here.
Not all symmetric monoidal categories are rigid. For a scheme , the category is symmetric monoidal, and its dualizable objects are precisely the vector bundles of finite rank. On an affine scheme this is the statement that dualizable modules are finite projective modules. Even contains infinite-dimensional objects, so the whole category is not rigid even for a one-point scheme.
Schur functors
We need one more finiteness property. Recall the representation-theoretic fact that, over a field of characteristic zero, the irreducible representations of the symmetric group are classified by partitions of . A partition is a sequence with
Write for the corresponding irreducible representation.
The symmetry gives a natural action of on for every . We define the Schur functor by
This formula makes sense inside . Tensoring an object with a finite-dimensional vector space is defined using finite direct sums, and taking invariants means taking the image of the averaging idempotent
Idempotents split in an abelian category. Thus we need not treat objects of as actual vector spaces in order to define . The dual on expresses the usual multiplicity-object convention; the irreducible representations of are self-dual, so it gives the same isomorphism class as the formula without the dual.
For example,
One can also use the enriched Yoneda embedding to regard as a full subcategory of -linear functors . Limits and colimits in that functor category are computed pointwise. This can help interpret the linear algebra, but the embedding alone does not provide the tensor or abelian properties needed for the constructions above; those are included in our hypotheses.
We say that is finitely generated by tensor products if there is an object from which every object is obtained using finite direct sums, tensor products, duals, and subquotients. Equivalently, after replacing the generator by , every object is a subquotient of a finite direct sum of its tensor powers, with the zeroth power interpreted as .
For example, the odd line tensor-generates : its square is the even line, and finite sums of the even and odd lines give all finite-dimensional super vector spaces.
Definition 3 (Schur-finiteness).¶ An object is Schur-finite if for some partition of some positive integer. Following the terminology of my notes, call a -tensor category regular if it is finitely generated by tensor products and every object is Schur-finite.
Schur-finiteness says that some irreducible -type is absent from the corresponding tensor power. In ordinary finite-dimensional vector spaces, sufficiently large exterior powers vanish. Super vector spaces require the more general Schur functors: an odd line has nonzero exterior powers in every degree, although its second symmetric power is zero.
The Deligne theorems
We can now describe the representation categories in the theorem. If is a Hopf superalgebra, an -module is a super vector space with an even action of the algebra . An -comodule is a super vector space with an even coaction
satisfying coassociativity and the counit identity. When is finite-dimensional, right -comodules correspond to left -modules, and vice versa. For general coordinate algebras, we keep the comodule description.
The Hopf structure gives tensor products of representations. For modules, the usual super symmetry is compatible with the action when is supercocommutative; for comodules, the corresponding condition is supercommutativity of . An arbitrary Hopf algebra does not automatically give a symmetric representation category.
Definition 4 (Affine supergroup).¶ An affine supergroup over is represented by a supercommutative Hopf superalgebra . Thus, for a supercommutative -algebra ,
with multiplication induced by , identity by , and inverse by . It is algebraic if is finitely generated as a superalgebra.
A finite-dimensional super-representation of is a finite-dimensional right -comodule. When the coordinate algebra is purely even, this includes the usual representations of affine group schemes by placing them in even degree.
Every superalgebra has a canonical parity involution, given on homogeneous elements by
For a supergroup it induces the parity automorphism of . An inner parity is an element such that and conjugation by is this parity automorphism. If is purely even, this says that is central; it need not be central for a general supergroup.
Fixing such , define to consist of finite-dimensional super-representations for which the action of is the parity involution of the representation. These form a -tensor category.
Theorem 5 (Deligne).¶ Let be an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, and let be a regular -tensor category in the sense above. There is an affine algebraic supergroup with inner parity and an equivalence
of symmetric tensor categories.
This is Deligne's Catégories tensorielles, Theorem 0.6. The tensor-generation hypothesis is what allows the reconstructed supergroup to be of finite type. The proof produces an exact faithful -linear symmetric monoidal functor
called a super fiber functor. Given this functor, the reconstruction takes the form
for every supercommutative -algebra . These are even -linear tensor automorphisms, natural in the objects of . The formula describes a functor on superalgebras, not just a group of -points. The parity automorphism of supplies .
For the forgetful functor on , this construction recovers and . Under the hypotheses stated here, the pair is unique up to isomorphism. The identification is not canonical without a choice of identification between fiber functors; changing that choice changes the resulting group isomorphism by conjugation.
The ordinary version
Recall that an affine group scheme is an affine -scheme equipped with a group-object structure. Taking spectra gives an anti-equivalence between commutative Hopf -algebras and affine group schemes. A simple example is
with , , and . Representations of an affine group scheme are finite-dimensional comodules over its coordinate Hopf algebra.
The ordinary Deligne theorem requires exterior powers, rather than arbitrary Schur functors, to vanish.
Theorem 6 (Deligne, ordinary form).¶ Let be algebraically closed of characteristic zero, and let be a -tensor category as in Definition 2. Suppose that for every object there is with . Then there is an affine group scheme and an equivalence
of symmetric tensor categories. If is finitely generated by tensor products, can be taken to be an affine algebraic group.
See Deligne's Catégories tannakiennes, Théorème 7.1, and Deligne–Milne, Tannakian Categories, including the discussion of the exterior-power criterion. Here the fiber functor takes values in , and
is evaluated on ordinary commutative -algebras. With a tensor generator, the same uniqueness discussion applies.
The difference in the hypotheses is visible in the simplest super example. The odd line in is Schur-finite but has no vanishing exterior power, so this category cannot be a category of ordinary representations with its usual symmetry. It is instead , with the symmetry determined by parity. This is why the super and ordinary reconstruction statements must be distinguished.
For the original short exposition and its references, see the paper version, Tannakian Reconstruction for Tensor Categories.